Final 2023 NFL Cornerback Rankings: Sauce Gardner retains his place as the No. 1 cornerback in the NFL

2T5TW9F New York Jets cornerback Sauce Gardner (1) reacts during the third quarter of an NFL football game against the Los Angeles Chargers, Monday, Nov. 6, 2023, in East Rutherford, N.J. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

• The one and only Sauce Gardner: The Jets cornerback earned the second-best coverage grade (90.8) at the position and ranked first among his peers when it came to preventing separation on all routes.

Jaylon Johnson‘s exceptional year: Johnson made the most of a contract year and delivered an absolutely stellar season. The Bears cornerback finished first in coverage grade and third in SCOE, and his all-around performance in coverage was a major factor for the Bears' late-season post-season push.

• Dig into the numbers for yourself: PFF's Premium Stats is the most in-depth collection of NFL and NCAA player performance data. Subscribe today to get full access!

Estimated Reading Time: 9 minutes


If quarterback is the most important position on the football field, then limiting the effectiveness of that player is the most important thing a defense can do.

A team can do this in two ways: It can pressure the passer to disrupt his timing, rhythm and accuracy, or it can shut down the opposing receivers.

These rankings will combine PFF coverage grades with our Successful Coverage Over Expected (SCOE) data, which looks at how well each coverage defender performed on non-targeted coverage snaps, as we grade every coverage defender’s ability to prevent separation whether they are targeted on the play or not.

Here are the top 32 cornerbacks for the 2023 season through Week 18. For more grades and statistics on the league's best cornerbacks, check out PFF Premium Stats.

Season Rank Change Player Team Grade Rank SCOE Rank
1 no change Sauce Gardner Jets 2 1
2 no change Jaylon Johnson Bears 1 3
3 up 3 Darious Williams Jaguars 4 7
4 no change Kendall Fuller Commanders 9 1
5 up 3 Derek Stingley Jr. Texans 5 8
6 up 1 Taron Johnson Bills 11 3
7 up 2 Michael Carter II Jets 7 9
8 down 5 Rasul Douglas Bills 6 13
9 down 4 Charvarius Ward 49ers 7 19
10 no change Kenny Moore II Colts 17 5
11 no change Mike Hilton Bengals 14 15
12 up 1 Brian Branch Lions 19 11
13 up 1 Christian Benford Bills 10 32
14 down 2 Trent McDuffie Chiefs 18 24
15 up 4 Tre Herndon Jaguars 25 19
16 no change Marcus Peters Raiders 33 15
17 up 1 L'Jarius Sneed Chiefs 34 17
18 up 9 Isaiah Oliver 49ers 35 17
19 down 2 Roger McCreary Titans 30 27
20 up 1 Joey Porter Jr. Steelers 39 14
21 down 1 Deommodore Lenoir 49ers 28 31
22 down 7 Steven Nelson Texans 25 37
23 up 10 Jonathan Jones Patriots 21 47
24 down 1 Donte Jackson Panthers 48 10
25 down 3 A.J. Terrell Falcons 23 48
26 up 7 Jamel Dean Buccaneers 52 5
27 down 2 Devon Witherspoon Seahawks 15 63
28 up 5 Jack Jones Raiders 31 42
29 up 1 Mekhi Blackmon Vikings 32 42
30 up 2 Paulson Adebo Saints 12 73
31 up 2 Tariq Woolen Seahawks 22 58
32 down 8 Denzel Ward Browns 38 34

HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE REGULAR SEASON

Best overall coverage defender: Sauce Gardner, New York Jets

Gardner followed up a ridiculous rookie season with another stellar campaign, retaining his place as the No. 1 cornerback in the NFL.

He earned the second-best coverage grade (90.8) at the position and ranked first among his peers when it came to preventing separation on all routes. He also allowed the second-fewest yards per cover snap (0.44) and finished third in forced incompletion rate (21.1%) and fourth in first downs allowed (11).

Gardner proved his elite-level play as a rookie was no fluke and that the Jets nailed their first-round pick in 2022.


Highest-graded coverage defender: Jaylon Johnson, Chicago Bears, 91.0

Johnson made the most of a contract year, delivering an absolutely stellar season. The Bears cornerback finished first in coverage grade and third in SCOE, and his all-around performance in coverage was a major factor for the Bears' late-season postseason push. He allowed a passer rating of just 33.3 when targeted while allowing a minuscule 195 yards and 0.37 yards per cover snap.


Most forced incompletions: Benjamin St-Juste, Washington Commanders (21)

St-Juste was the fourth-most-targeted cornerback in the NFL and, as a result, had several opportunities to get his hands on the ball. He did so more than any other cornerback, even though his forced incompletion rate ranked 11th at his position. As a result of being heavily targeted, St-Juste also allowed the most first downs during the regular season. 


Top-ranked in SCOE: Sauce Gardner, New York Jets and Kendall Fuller, Washington Commanders

We've already waxed poetic about Gardner and his amazing season, so now Fuller gets his due.

The Washington cornerback did his best to keep his defense together as he locked down opposing receivers week after week. His 82.8 coverage grade ranked ninth in the NFL, with his 21 pass stops good for third. While he did give up six touchdown passes, Fuller allowed just 13 first downs and produced the ninth-best first down/touchdown rate in the NFL.


Lowest completion percentage allowed (minimum five targets): Joey Porter Jr., Pittsburgh Steelers (41.4%)

The Pittsburgh Steelers found themselves a difference-maker at the top of the second round of the 2023 NFL Draft, as the former Penn State Nittany Lion was a menace for opposing receivers.

Porter was targeted 58 times but allowed just 24 catches for 352 yards and one touchdown, with quarterbacks managing a passer rating of just 60.4 when throwing in his direction.


Most pass stops: Taron Johnson, Buffalo Bills (23)

Cornerbacks can't always control the number of catches they allow. Sometimes, the scheme of the defense is to force a check down underneath a defender’s coverage area, and there are also times when the offense calls a screen pass.

However, what happens after that point is in the defender's control. Johnson made the most of his situation and made tackles for defensive wins. His 5.0-yard average depth of target was third-lowest in the NFL, and he did an excellent job preventing separation downfield.


Lowest expected points added per target: Jaylon Johnson, Chicago Bears (-0.319)

Johnson allowing the fewest expected points added (EPA) per target shouldn’t be much of a surprise to anyone. After all, he gave up a completion rate of 46.3%, just eight first downs, one touchdown and 195 yards with four interceptions (one of which he returned for a touchdown). It was a special season for Johnson, who should be paid extremely well this offseason. 

Safety worth way more than 2 points. Help protect your family with fast, free will.
Sponsor
NFL Featured Tools
Subscriptions

Unlock the 2024 Fantasy Draft Kit, with Live Draft Assistant, Fantasy Mock Draft Sim, Rankings & PFF Grades

$24.99/mo
OR
$119.99/yr